Monday, January 24, 2011

Learning to Love Linux

My entire family has been converted to Linux.  While I drove the adoption as the tech support in residence, the conversion wasn't always met with open arms by all.  In the end the the fear of the unknown was overcome and everyone did learn to (mostly) love Linux.

This post is a summary of the applications that have helped in that adoption.  There are many Windows to Linux application equivalence charts.  This won't be another one.  Nor is this a detailed analysis of the merits of various alternative applications.  Instead, like most posts on this site, is more statement of what worked for us, with minimal explanation.

User Interface

This is the area where adoption begins - initial navigation.  Being able to find, start and stop programs is crucial.  Like it or not, the 800 pound gorilla is Windows and it's navigation paradigm.  Following it has benefits both in home adoption and in transferring skills to systems outside the home, such as at school.  Based primarily on that plus overall out-of-the box functionality, Linux Mint is our main choice, however we have at least one of each below.
  • Linux Mint - best Windows equivalent:  start menu, taskbar, min/max/close buttons
  • Ubuntu - the foundation for the other two distributions:  inverted UI for Windows users, a lot of "the same only different"
  • UNE (was UNR) - Screen optimized for netbooks:  nothing the same here, launcher very unique
Identical - Linux

These applications comprise most of the home computer usage in our family.  Either originally on Windows or once converted to Linux, these are identical.  It should probably be noted that no one is a PC gamer.  Those that enjoy those use dedicated consoles.

 Office above refers to Open Office, which is cross platform.  Since most home users don't use 3% of the installed function of Office applications, switch the default file type to the Microsoft format (for sharing) and you'll never know the difference.



    Alternatives - Linux

    These are the native Linux applications that round out the functions wanted by the family.  Note that these links are given for information only.  Applications are installed via the package manager within a Linux system, not via web downloads.
    • Banshee - music manager and mp3 sync.  Syncs perfectly to multiple mp3 players and Android.
    • Songbird - music manager and iPod sync.  We have only one iPod owner and this works well for him.
    • Totem movie player - DVD playback.  VLC has more options and may be use less CPU though.
    • apcupsd - software control for APC UPS.  Battery operation options for UPS.
    • gnuCash - accounting software.  Amazing software, gave it 14 months of usage, but switched back to Quicken.
    • simplescan - multi sheet scanning to PDF.  The 300Mb+ of HP Solution Center is gone.
    • Tomboy - cross platform - sticky notes, useful with DropBox. 
    Productivity - Linux

    Many people create written content either to send (email), print (documents) or remember (sticky notes).  Those that make a discipline out of creating content, in the hope they'll be more productive, might be interested in these.
    • Nevernote - an open source, cross platform (near) clone of Evernote, focused on creating the "missing" Linux client
    • Rednotebook - an open source, cross platform (including Windows portable version) journal and calendar application
    Alternatives - Cloud

    A switch in operating systems might also be a good time to look at cloud, or web based services.  Consider your access, storage and security needs.  You may find this is a good time to move to a computer anywhere model.
    • Springpad - cross platform, web and mobile. Social and email linkage.  If I ever switched from Evernote, this would be it.  Maybe when I upgrade to Android 2.1, hmmm.
    • Mint - Owned by Intuit, "Quicken Lite" - limited to pulling 3 months history when starting, relatively inflexible categories, very coarse grained tax designations.  But, like GnuCash, great for a free application.
    • Google Docs - All office type applications and data are web based.  The performance lag, plus existing critical mass keep me from this, but there is a lot of positives if starting fresh.
    • Dropbox - cross platform, web and mobile.  Synchronized file access for all your computers via the web.  Allows access from any web browser.
    Identical - Wine

    This section gives me a deja vu from my time as a OS/2 Version 3 (aka Warp) support engineer.  The Win 3.x compatibility and IBM's inability to market small systems led to OS/2s downfall, but I digress.  In any event, while trying alternatives I did test the following two 32bit Windows applications, which worked perfectly for everything I tested under Wine 1.2 (Windows emulator):
    • Quicken 2009 - personal finance management
    • Evernote 3.1 - tagged note taking, cross platform (except Linux), web and mobile

      Don't Need

      A short list of some of the things you'll no longer need to have bogging down your system, keeping updated or having to spend.
      • Anti-Virus
      • Anti-Spyware
      • Disk Defrag
      • Adobe Reader
      • PDF Writer
      • Proprietary Scanner
      • Validation
      • Upgrade $$$
      Problems

      Linux is not Utopian computing.  At the end of the day there are still some computer "they're all like that" issues - see the "mostly" comment at the start.  This is our short list of items that I haven't solved due to time, expertise or interest.  One of our Linux Mint systems loses X-Windows only occasionally when two users are logged in.  The UNE system uses a launcher that removed Places which makes local file sharing more inconvenient than it should be.  Our lowest end system (1.8Ghz/512Mb) runs movies better on WinXP, although everything else runs better under Linux Mint.  If none of these situations apply (or make sense to you), have no worries.

      Still not sure?  Try one of the Live CD distributions.  While the actual boot is about 20 times slower than off a hard drive, you'll have full functionality once its up and running.  It will even allow installations (for that session) of additional software.

      Hopefully this can be a small additional resource to those considering the move to Linux or just starting out.  Net:  the benefits far outweigh the small learning curve to be climbed.  You just might end up loving it.

      Enjoy.

        2 comments:

        1. While your observation that most people don't use 3% of the office suite they have, OpenOffice has stalled a bit. Have you tried LibreOffice on any of the machines yet? The whole Libre Office Foundation as a spin-off of OOo is a bit confusing, but LibreOffice has been moving a bit more of late.

          ReplyDelete
        2. I've seen some good words written on LibreOffice and the reason behind starting it, but we collectively haven't needed anything yet that OO can't do.

          ReplyDelete